1 sunken colony vs 2 photon cannons vs 1 bunker + 4 marines

But as the Bunker falls, the Bunker is no longer the winner if the Marines win afterwards - the Marines are. So, I agree the Marines should afterwards stop counting...

 

Besides, bunkers are virtually useless without marines or firebats or ghosts.

 

mmm... I think cannons may win because they have shields. If you locate them well... I think thay will win,,, I mean, locate them in opposite sides of the enemy building. The sunken colony maybe attack only one of them or ramdomly... Now, with bunkers... mmm... I think that marines will attack the closest cannon, so the attack gets shorted,,, only half of it for each cannon.

Between sunken and bunker,,, I think bunker will win but,, marines will concentrate their attack.

Under different conditions maybe marines will win, if you stim-pack them before entering the bunker but I think this is out of this topic so sorry,, just want to say that because stim pack are awesome hehe

 

hmm i agree with alucardx

bunker might win if the marines have the upgrades with is

9 atk + stim + longer range

9 x 4 = 36

stim = faster atk

longer range = bunker farther away

 

Bunker wins easily if you put ghosts in there, they have an incredibly long range when inside bunkers. It's about 9 or so because it out ranges the guardian which is 8.

 

photon cannons... because you said 2 cannons versus one of them so 2 would beat 1 on normal defence

 

it heals so slow over time it wouldnt matter that much... maybe only 1 extra hit against it or 0

 

lol k

 

the ammount it will heal in battle wouldnt even equal 1 more attack from the enemy, so it doesnt make a difference.

 

thats what i said up there ^^

 

It's always possible that it's just these few hitpoints it needed to win... but yeah... :

 

sorry, didn't read the whole thread, but these numbers are wrong.

sunken is 50(drone) + the 125, making it 175.

4 marines are only 200 minerals, so it comes out to 300.

 

So to make it equal cost wise you would need 2 bunkers with 2 marines each, and 2 sunks

 

1 pylon (100) + 1 cannon (150) = 250
vs.
1 Bunker (100) + 3 Marines(150) = 250


1 Sunken + 1 zergling = 200
vs.
1 bunker + 2 Marines = 200


1 pylon + 1 cannon + 1 zealot = 350
vs.
Sunken + sunken = 350

Fairest way that I can think will work to test them.

 

The problem with counting the pylon is that the cost of it is way to much for 1 photon cannon because generally 1 pylon is suppoting 3-5 cannons. I would say if your gonna count it count it per 4 photon cannons or 25 per cannon

 

No you cant say that because even if you have 1 photon cannon you need that 1 pylon which is 100 mins. You cant buy part of the pylon for 25 just because you are using only 1 cannon

 

i think the photon cannons would win, but i guess it does depend on the units in the bunker. also, the photon cannons are the most expensive.

 

bunker wins coz the marines would go berserk before they go inside the bunkers gving them hyperspeed atk mode lol

 

Guys, the question has been answered already.

See this post for the conclusion

And see this post for the actual experiment done by Whatsifsowhatsif

 

woulden't the bunker acually win? If the marines went out of it and attacked, the bunker would always win wouldent it? But since you made it so that the marines can't attack after... I guess not.