who will win? all starcraft race or star wars? terran only vs starwars?

i dont know. what do you think? maybe star craft the terrans are more badazz than the starwars clones and droids.

 

What has starwars got to do with starcraft?

Anyway i think if the powers of zerg, terran and protoss combined it would beat starwars characters.
but this is not a good comparison

 

Yea, what starwars got to do with starcraft?

If you are talking about the original SC, I think it will be a close fight, but I think SC will still own Starwars. Jedi vs High Templar : Psionic storm = dead Jedi. Jedi can block lasers, but can they block bullets?

If it's SC2 in this case, just think about the mothership. It owns every single starwars unit. Not even the death star comes close

 

star wars vs starcraft? because both has star on it. LOL. do you think the droids or clones laser can penetrate a terran marine armor in a single shot? if not. star craft wins! jedi will easily kill marines tho. there are also some huge spaceships in starwars too. ow, chubacass are no match for firebats. heheh. fried chubacasss. hahah. dont get me wrong. i like star wars too, stars wars revenge of the sith is on my number 8th list of all time fave movies. heheh. soory bout my english ;D you guys are good in english. whats your secrets? read more? if your americans nevermind answering. heheh.

 

starwars is set in a long long long time ago
starcraft is set in 500 years into the future - 2500

starwars started mainly as a movie series
starcraft started mainly as a RTS computer game

starwars's characters are mostly humans
starcraft has humans and 2 alien species

There's really no comparison, they are just too different. even their story is different.

 

terran alone would win. a cloaked wraith would destroy countless tie and x fighters. the death star could be taken down by a few dozen yamatos, if nothing gets in the way, courtesy of wraiths. as we saw in attack of the clones, the number of bullets that 20 or so marines can shoot will kill the jedi. the only real hope starwars has is for the jedi to sneak up and whore out force lightning and mind control.

 

Well, if you put the Republic and CIS, or the Empire and the Rebels together, they would beat the Terrans....But either other race would pwn them.

 

Ok, I'm really, really sorry, but what are you guys smoking? If you pit the Star Wars Universe against the StarCraft Universe, the Star Wars Universe would decimate poor StarCraft. These are both fictional Universes, both take some liberties with interpretations of what is possible, but as it happsn, the Star Wars Universe goes a little(a lot) more overboard than StarCraft, and so ends up having more to work with.

In most cases, StarCraft units would defeat their Star Wars analog in 1 on 1 combat, but in the end, the sheer size of the Imperial Army/Navy would overpower the three races of StarCraft. It is a military force funded by an entire galaxy (more or less) and hundreds, if not thousands of planets and different alien civilizations. I take my examples from the Star Wars Universe under the Galactic Empire, because it was much more militant than the Republic, and more is known about its army.

Death Star(s) + Super Star Destroyer(s) vs Protoss Mothership: According to Star Wars cannon (if I recall correctly), along with the two Death Stars featured in the films, there were something like 2 other full Death Stars, and a few more smaller stations with the same planet buster beam being built in other parts of the galaxy. Along with Vader's Super Star Destroyer, some sources suggest there was another one. Let me note that Death Stars are freakin' huge. A Super Star Destroyer dwarfs Star Destroyers, and a Death Star dwarfs a Super Star Destroyer by another two orders of magnitude. These things presumably house thousands of fighters and other ships, have near-impenetrable shields, and have guns that can blow up planets. Not even the Protoss have anything nearly this insane. The closest thing StarCraft can throw at these large ships is a Mothership, and while it may be city-sized, there is no way it would survive a direct blast from a Death Star's main gun.

A wraith has shielding and firepower somewhere between an X-Wing and a heavy TIE. While it may be able to take down several, the Empire has thousands, if not tens of thousands of TIEs, and I am certain that the Empire’s capital ships and bases have equipment that would qualify as a “detector†that could spot cloaked Wraiths. The Rebels have something like several hundred to a thousand fighters, and most of them are nowhere near as strong as an X-Wing. Of course, StarCraft’s Scout is stronger than any fighter-class ship in Star Wars, but in the end, sheer numbers will win out.

A Death Star is a sphere with a diameter of 180km. You couldn’t take one down with a dozen nukes, let alone a dozen. Yamatos. And this is assuming it has its shields down, which it won’t.

JedI don’t normally engage in direct combat, and at Imperial times, there were only a few Jedi left anyway. Realistically, a Marine could take out all Star Wars infantry, and many of its lighter vehicles. But the sheer size of the armies, with air and artillery support would overpower any StarCraft ground force.

You could argue that Ghosts or Dark Templar could do the same for StarCraft. If such covert ops were employed, though, each side would probably be able to deal similar amounts of damage to the other. StarCraft has some very powerful "special forces" units, but they are all mortal to enough gunfire, and there is plenty of firepower to go around when you're talking about the Empire's capacities.

Imperial Star Destroyers vs StarCraft capital ships: While they are roughly the same size as a Battlecruiser or Carrier, they are much stronger. Unlike a Battlecruiser, they have shields and can carry fighters. We might assume that true-scale Battlecruisers can carry fighters (in the cinematics they have a good 6-8 launch bays), but they're not built with that as a primary function. Battlecruisers also have fewer guns than Battlecruisers. Even scaled up, we would only expect the Battlecruiser to have a dozen small lasers to complement the main batteries and the Yamato Cannon. A scaled-up Carrier would probably have a larger carrier capacity than a Star Destroyer, and better shields, but it would also have inferior weapons. In a realistic StarCraft Universe, there would probably be fewer than a hundred Battlecruisers and Carriers in operation: they aren't cheap to make or maintain. In the Star Wars Universe, while large ships like Star Destroyers would still be expensive to build and maintain, the Empire happens to have a much larger economy to back them, so they can afford to keep multiple hundreds of these ships in operation.

 

all 3 starcraft races? now u got to be kiddin me. have you seen star wars episodes IV, V, VI? all the small airships in starwars will be pwned by starcraft units like phoenix, wraith, scout etc (they have a lot of skills unlike starwars aircrafts). anakin and obiwan's spacecraft in episode 3 are jokes compaerd to starcraft airships! episode 1 (young anakin) the rebellion small airship sucks! their like toys. heheh. x wing fighter is slow, cloking starcraft aircrafts clowns them all. the v ship aircraft (i guess that would be the star destroyers) in starwars can be destroyed by warp rays (new protoss air unit) or even by scouts. i think scouts and wraiths travel fast they will confuse stardestroyers while repeatedly fire their weapons on it. BOOM! DROIDS? hahah. clones? hahah. they will have a hard time killing a marine. clones toy guns can hardly kill zealot s with their shields, and by the time zealots gets close to them, 3-8 droids or clones will be dead before the zealot dies (in reality zealots laser weapons can kill a clown o mean clone in one strike! and zealots are fast) empire strikes back? siege tanks is more than enough to finish off those walking 4 legged robots. EVEN THE IMPERIAL ARMY IS HAVING A PROBLEM WITH EWOKS! STARCRAFT ARE WAR TESTED, NOT MEDIOCRE. I THINK STARWARS HAS A LITTLE SOFT SIDE IN THEM WHEN IT COMES TO WAR, imperial army are kind of lame, remember when han solo and his crew try to take over the station in the jungle (terrans will not take anything for granted, this guys are way tougher than the imperial army) (STARWARS ARE RICHER, BUT TERRANS FOCUS MORE ON DEVELOPING FIRE POWERED WEAPONS AND ARMOR, while starwars focus more on the city of couresant. hahah.) Clones have plastic armor, terran have achilles armor. heheh. MIND CONTROL THOSE STAR DESTROYERS! DEATH STAR PLANET DESTROYER IS RARE. GET INSIDE (maybe a ghost can do this) DESTROY THE SHIELD GENERATOR THEN NUKE EM. NUKE THE JEDI TEMPLE! hehe. Attack of the clones, a couple of carrier will kill a lot starwars unit on that dessert war. psionic storms, dragond, zealots, scouts, revers on that dessert war. NO NEED TERRAN NO NEED ZERG!

sorry. HEY I LIKE STARWARS MOVIE! BUT WHEN THESE TWO HEAD TO HEAD? il be routing for starcraft! or even TERRANS ONLY!

about their unlimited clones. NUKE em all. heheh. or starcraft will find a way to travel like obiwan and destroy the clone developers in that planet. ;D

Starcraft movie. now thats great. dont compare it to starship troopers please. THAT MOVIE SUCKS LIKE SHIT! and terran will pwn those annoying troopers and alien bugs and their brain that looks like....SHIIIIIITTTTT!!!!

Sorry man, but star craft WINS! ZERATUL AND KERIGAN WILL TAKE ON THE BEST JEDI's like obiwan and anakin mano e mano. ;D

 

ow by the way those other alizen civilazation ur talkin about. they wont dare come between the so called starwars starcraft wars! JAVA and his worm better not even talk about this wars or zerglings will eat him off.

not thousand of planets! maybe hundred of starwars planets which most of them are not occupied..hahah. come on, their just planets, terran have seen a lot. LETS TALK ABOUT THE BEST THING HERE. IMPERAIL ARMY IS THE BEST THING STARWARS CAN OFFER (thats why they are the bullies of the galaxy, not until starcraft came along, heheh.). and for starcraft any 3 of the races. well ZERG will take care of those "other alien civilazation" the flying insects in episode 2 (hydralisk will spit and screw them to the ground) , java and his pig army, the aliens in episode 2 where general grievous hides, the chubacas, the EWOKS! ..heheh. kerrigan will kill the bounty hunter. ZERG WILL EAT THEM ALL! ;D

OW YEAH INFESTED DROIDS AND CLONES WILL WHACK ANY SWARM OF STARWARS ALIEN CIVILAZATION.

AND U KNOW WHAT THE IMPERIAL ARMY WEAKNESSES ARE? WELL ONE THING! DEATH STAR! NO DEATH STAR=GAME OVER! THE REBELLION WHICH IS A NOVICE VERSION OF THE TERRAN WAS ABLE TO DESTROY THE DEATH STAR AND BEAT VADER AND HIS GOONS. TERRAN WILL SURELY FINISH THE JOB MORE QUICKLY THAN THE REBELLION!!! OW AS IN THE STARCRAFT UNIVERSE STORY, NO RACES HAS BEEN DEFEATED YET, AND IT WILL GO ON UNTIL BLIZZARD SHUTDOWNS--> IT MEANS THAT THERE IS NOT MUCH OF A WEAKNESS IN STARCRAFT RACES. AND POOR STARWARS HAS ONE MAIN WEAKNESS WHICH IS THE DEATH STAR.

JUST THINK ABOUT THIS> WHO WILL WIN? PROTOSS OR THE STARWARS REBELLION? PROTOSS WILL KILL THEM EASILY, like taking a candy from a baby. so its now protoss and IMPERAIL ARMY, protoss is way smarter than the rebellions..

as in the movie the death star is vulnerable with no shield and has no good defense to it. VADER EVEN RIDES A SPACECRAFT TO DEFEND THE DEATH STAR IN EPISODE IV. hahah. now a mothership and a dozen of carriers floating a death star = a crying sith LORD. heheh.

I THINK PROTOSS IS HIGHLY MORE ADVANCE IN TECHNOLOGY AND SCIENCE THAN STAR WARS. PROTOSS HAS MAGIC TOO WHICH IS SWEEEEETTTT. AND COMPARE THE DETAILS AND EFFECTS OF PROTOSS SPACE CRAFT THAN THAT OF STARWARS. PROTOSS ARE DETAILED. HEHEH. ITS NOT LIKE ITS GOIN TO HELP. but PROTOSS ROCKS BIG TIME! MOTHERSHIPS HAS ABILITY TO SLOW DOWN WAEPON, maybe the death star planet destroyer maybe be slowed down to and diminished. what if the protoss fleets are at the back of the death star and the planet destroyer laser of the death star is at front. hhahahahah. BLACK HOLE THOSE STAR DESTROYERS. well in the game its not much, but in reality BLACK HOLES BLANKS EVERYTHING.

 

I LOVE STARWARS MOVIE THO. WHAT WAS I THINKING POSTING THIS TOPIC....wwwaaaaahhhh. :upset:

 

owerdown:

I am not even going to try to read that.

Typing in caps does not increase your credibility. Typing in caps is not cruise control for cool. On the Internet it is exactly equivalent to yelling. Don't do it.

 

OH MY GOD! Im not yelling or anything. i just want my points to be clear. wwaaaahhh. im so sorry. can you read it now? its nothing personal, like i said im a big starwars fan. im not mad about you, this is the best part (its not arguments)... its FUN! im still sorry tho, ive learned my lessons. whats up with the power level anyway. :

 

ok i admit it. i was kinda of mad when i read your topic. so stupid of me, i posted this topic and asking for your opinions and i angrily denied your opinion. forgive me :upset: yah, im not a class act unlike you :thumbup:

 

Lasers ARE light actually....By definition. Anyhoo, the people in the SW universe technically don't use laser guns, they use "blasters," and in the novels, a distinction is made. Anyways, a Jedi wouldn't need to deflect bullets, they'd go all Matrix on 'em.
And a Jedi would pwn a Dark Templar. Just because they're invisible means nothing. A Jedi would sense them.

In the end, taking in all the other arguments, StarCraft is much cooler, but come on. You seriously don't think they can win?

 

hey. if your raed all my post starcraft can actually win! don't underestimate the dark templar yo. because we have not seen templars in a movie, so we really don't know their stuffs and what they can really do Grin

most of the jedi are not good at fighting. attack of the clones for examples most of them died in random laser attack and laser blast, even the bounty is a killer of jedi. hhhmmmm, i think the bounty hounter is an even match against a ghost or a couple of good marines. Smiley

they can't sense them that easily. wow! most of the jedi's are not powerful. dark templar + the new dark templar (blink ability) will pwn them jedis. rounds of bullets fired can only be dodge matrix style by neo trained as a jedi.

if you say starwars can win against starcraft. thats a joke. (starcraft=all 3 races). starwars will have a hard time fighting the protoss, how much more with the terrans and zerg. they whill be doom if they fight all 3 races.

yah, Jedi's are cool and powerful. but we have not seen starcraft much in real life only in few cinematics in SC1 which is lame. the combined blue giant templar (i forgot the name) is pretty much a threat to starwars, its very powerful even general grievous will fear it. come on. do you know the units of star wars? read all my post please.

if starwars has sheer numbers. they are still beatable because they have weaknesses. the death star and some jedis. Grin

 

just to show how powerful and strong marines are. imagine hundred of thousands of them. ;D

 

FFS! Stop spamming man, you're really annoying the heck out me. Use the modify button and do not post 3 message after each other. And don't post messages like this:

What's the use?

 

Yes, we know that StarCraft units are strong. As I said, if they were to go head to head, the StarCraft units would win, but when you take into account entire armies, Star Wars troops would overwhelm them with sheer numbers... or just blow up the whole planet, whichever comes first.

---

coalescence is right: spamming is really annoying and rude. Incidentally, one-word posts are against the rules for that very reason.