New VS: Starcraft universe vs Warhammer 40K universe

Inspired by the starcraft vs star wars topic.

I love Starcraft more, but I Vote for 40K!
Necrons, stargods and daemons... no dealing with that.

 

i dont know 40k. guess i have to reasearch for it. are you abandoning the starwars stracraft war? wweeeeeeeeee. yey! victory for starcraft! .heheh. ;D

lets go guys for starcraft 2 sakes. lets vote starcraft! starcraft! starcraft! starcraft! starcraft! starcraft! starcraft! starcraft!

starwars vs starcrafts topic (for all those having a second thought) read all my post please. and all my starcraft alliance its time tto unite. heheh. starcraft starcraft starcraft! wins!

 

you cant realy compare the two on a civilizations standpoint cause warhammer has looaads of fluff
if we looked at isolated battles then
spacemarines >>terrans
terrans > IG
protoss >> eldar
Tyranids > zerg
protoss > space marines
protoss >> tau
chaos convert terrans

no idea where orcs come in lols

 

I know, its actually quite stupid. But its a better comparison than starcraft vs star wars ;D

 

starcraft vs lotr
infested boromir

 

Infested teletubbie

 

a ultralisk vs a troll, hammers vs kaiser blades
or
helms deep being rushed by 10,000 zerglings

 

Enough of the bollocks

 

lol
yeah i get it

 

siege at minas tirith. orcs with siege tanks ^_^

war hammer? is this an old game. is this a good game? if it is, then im going to download it.

when was this game released? wow! they have counter units for starcraft. hhmm. starcraft wins? heheh.

 

That said; WH40k takes place around the year 40.000 while StarCraft takes place around the year 2500.

 

If nesassary we can always get the 'toss to mind control some 40k arse.

 

Tell me this won't be StarCraft vs Star Wars all over again. Warhammer would beat StarCraft for the same reasons that Star Wars would beat StarCraft, except I don't know enough about the universe to begin laying out the details. Can someone knowledgeable start us off with a strong argument so that certain members won't blindly argue that StarCraft will destroy absolutely everything?

 

i don't have much excperience with Wharhammer, but is it not like the races have been fighting since the ancient time until year 40k or more? Heard it on a interwiev with a guy.. The races are fighting eachother for non very good reasons and they have fought in ALL EVER! I find that kind of stupid... Someone would have been eliminated by that time.

 

I REALY LOVE 40K AND STARCRAFT!

But the only thin that separes the two games is THE HISTORY
in warhammer 40k the SPACE MARINES are a rece created by a emperor
god of the imperium, the TERRAN MARINES they are sended outside the galaxy
for conquest others planet

 

space marines >>terrans
terrans > IG
protoss >> eldar
Tyranids > zerg
protoss > space marines
protoss >> tau
chaos convert terrans

 

I realy fell that you doesn´t now what are you talking abaut
I said, I just saiying :-X :-X

Because you havent played it for now but is realy cool
the terran can be like The imperial Guard
the zerg like the tiranids and the protoss like the eldar

 

I think that 40k would win. If all the 40k races went up against all the Starcraft races, i think that 40k would win in a matter or minutes. 11 races vs 3. Easily a win for 40k. But if you are talking how cool the games are, Starcraft would win then.
Heres a how I think a few matchups would work out.
Tyranids vs Zerg
Tyranids attack in Hive Fleets, which have multiple broods. Each brood holds multiple hive ships. Each ship holds thousands of tyranid creatures. These creatures range from the tiny to the colossal, and even the smallest (Rippers) can take down men easily. They also have powerful psychic cratures and towering brutes so strong a single one can destroy an entire tank unit (Carnifexs RULE!!!). Zerg attack in large swarms, which are part of a brood. These swarms never number in the thousands. They do have the big and small creatures like tyranids, and each are very deadly. And even Defilers and queens use powerful energy, but they can't match the pure power of Hivelords and Zoanthropes. And they don't devour all life on a planet to create new ships and creatures before moving on to the next one. Tyranids, the Devourer of Worlds, wins this match up.

Space Marines vs Terran
Space Marines are highly trained warriors who fight in the name of the God Emporer. They use powerful weapons that can punch holes in thick armor, and have a variety of machines to take to war. They have Dreadnaughts which hold the soul of a dead hero in a metal mech. Titans, giant machines that can crush even the largest enemies benteath thier feet plus have awsome guns. All space marines are members of a certain Chapter, each chapter having it's own special training styles (ex, Space Wolves have higher Initiative). Terran proudly uses convicts as thier soldiers, forcing them to fight as a penelty for thier crime. Goliaths and siege tanks are powerful assets on the battle field, and they can quickly lay waste to enemy bases. Wraiths are quick units that can assult weak points in basses and take out enemy fliers easily. Batlecruisers are weapons of unstobalbe power (well, almost). They can kill small units in only a few hits, and they have a powerful secondary beam which can severly damage buildings and kill almost any opponent it fights. This one was a hard decision, but i think Space Marines take home a win for the Emporer.

I wont compare any of the other races from 40k, because I don't know very much about them. If someone could compare Protoss to something, please do. The remaining 40k races are:

Orks
Eldar
Dark Eldar
Chaos
Necrons
Witch Hunters
Imperial Guard
Tau
Daemonhunters

 

I'm pretty sure the lack of Nukes in WH40k automatically makes SC win it but whatev.

The Zerg Swarm is millions of Zerg. I dunno who the hell said the swarm didnt number in the thousands, but you're just plain ridiculous. The Zerg wiped out their creators a race far surpassing anything else. Planet eater? How's about that planeteater try to fight the overmind a being that spawns it's own lieutenants and extends it's control of it's minions hundreds of lightyears away. Not to mention the fact it can essentially warp out to any destination it so chooses (seen in the final episode of SC Original, it attempts to escape before Tassadar Kamikaze's it.) Carnifex? Suck my Torrasque bitch.

Space Marines. Fanatical troops with dope weaponry and training. Terran Marines. Psychopathic killers with dope weaponry and training. Thats hard to choose. That giant ass Mech from WH40K is pretty pimp, but En-Masse Gol Anti-air would rip it. Also keep in mind the new Thor unit. If it has any upgraded qualities to the Goliath, Space Marines lose. The wraith? I dont remember Space Marines having anything that could cloak. Reapers are essentially the same as Jump jet infantry. BC's would rwn Space Marine capital ships due to Yamato Cannons. The siege tank can fire miles away and devastate. What can the Rhino do? Shoot shitty shells at visual distance? The only thing cool that the Space marines have that would be effective would be the Terminators but they would get rwnt by Air and by long range attacks. OH yeah and most importantly.... Nuclear Launch Detected.

I cant comment on the Eldar, as I know nothing about them. But, the Protoss fucking destroy worlds. For sport. I dont even need to say anything else.

 

Ya in my Tyranids Codex it even talks about a single ship calling down Melta Torpedos and wiping out all the life on the planet. One Ghost or one Battle Cruiser can't do that now can they?
And the Hive Mind doesn't spawn it's own lieutenants, It spawns it's own Norn Queens, which then spawn their own armies. And the Hive Mind wasn't created by another race, it is way to powerful for that. Although it has destroyed countless races and almost wiped out all human life (and would have too if it weren't for some virus made in the battle of Tarsis Ultra). And the Hive Mind isn't even a true creature that can be killed. It is a psychic entity that cannot be killed and that is truly wherever it wants to be.
Marines in SC don't have training. You saw the trailer. They just get armor strapped on and are given a gun and told to shoot until they die. Space Marine go though Genetic Engineering, long and extremely hard training, and are then told to stop the advance of technologically advanced or impossibly numbered armies. And Goliaths would never be able to take down Titans. Titans can destroy thousands of enemies with one missile. Thors might stand a chance against rhinos, but even they would need at least 12 to take down a titan. And BC's would be hopeless against the Space Marine Battle Barges, which could kill just about any opposing ship, and the Strike Cruisers would take down Valkyries and Wraiths. Wraiths do have the cloak advantage, I will give them that. And Im sure that the Space Mrines have some sort of artillery that could out range the siege tanks. If not, orbital ships could just torpedo them.

But as with the Eldar vs Protoss, I wouls say toss win. Eldar is a dying race, and toss is just getting stronger as time goes on.